The Implications of an ISIS Invasion on North Sentinel Island: A Hypothetical Scenario

I recently came across a fascinating thought experiment that explores the consequences of an ISIS invasion on North Sentinel Island. The premise is intriguing: What if all Islamic countries united and ISIS successfully invaded North Sentinel Island? Would India and other nations care, or would they stand by without intervention?

Geography and Isolement of North Sentinel Island

To understand the implications of such a scenario, it is important to first note the inaccessibility of North Sentinel Island, located in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands of India. This island is home to the Sentinelese people, an indigenous tribe that has chosen to remain isolated from the rest of the world. The Sentinelese have a unique status as recognized by Indian law, and attempting to land on the island carries severe legal and ethical consequences.

Hypothetical Scenario: ISIS Invades North Sentinel Island

In this hypothetical scenario, we imagine that ISIS, despite its significant military capabilities, attempts to invade North Sentinel Island. This is highly improbable due to several factors:

Hostility of the Sentinelese: Known for their ferocity and rejection of outside contact, the Sentinelese are likely to fiercely resist any invaders. Their hunting and fishing skills, honed over thousands of years, provide them with a strategic advantage. Indian Naval Presence: The Indian government has a persistent naval presence in the surrounding waters. It is highly probable that any attempt to invade North Sentinel Island would be intercepted and thwarted by the Indian navy. Ethical Concerns: The invasion of this isolated community would be a gross violation of human rights and a moral outrange. The global community would most likely condemn such actions, making it virtually impossible for ISIS to achieve its objectives.

Consequences for ISIS if Successful

Assuming ISIS somehow manages to invade and conquer North Sentinel Island, there could be significant long-term consequences:

Financial Gain: The GDP of ISIS could theoretically benefit from the resources and potential tourism revenue. Expanded Territory: The invasion would result in an expansion of ISIS's territory, which could further fuel their ambitions. Global Condemnation: Such an invasion would likely elicit strong global condemnation, leading to widespread sanctions and diplomatic isolation.

Critique of the Original Scenarios

The original scenario presented several inaccuracies and misconceptions. Firstly, it incorrectly suggests that any attempt by ISIS to invade North Sentinel Island would be met without consequence, despite the Sentinelese's fierce resistance and the Indian government's naval presence. Additionally, it makes a dubious claim that an army of emperors or presidents (such as a hypothetical "emperor Trumposky") could have potentially destroyed ISIS, which does not match historical and current data.

Final Thoughts

It is important to acknowledge the illegal and unethical nature of any military action against the Sentinelese people. They are a simple and isolated tribe, and harming them would be a grave moral sin. The global community should prioritize their protection and respect for their rights to self-determination.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the hypothetical scenario presented in the original thought experiment is more fiction than reality. The Sentinelese people, with their unique culture and survival skills, along with the strong naval presence of the Indian government, make an ISIS invasion of North Sentinel Island highly unlikely and morally reprehensible.