Why Staten Island is Considered Less Popular Than Other NYC Boroughs and Why It Deserves More Love

Often dismissed as the 'lesser' borough of New York City due to its relative isolation and past challenges, Staten Island has long been viewed with a mix of pride and frustration by its residents. Let's explore why Staten Islanders felt the need to distance themselves from the city and delve into the realities of living in this vibrant island.

Staten Island’s Distinct Identity

Staten Islanders have always had a strong sense of uniqueness and a desire to distance themselves from the other boroughs. This can be traced back to historical and political factors. City Journal once coined Staten Island as 'New Yorker shorthand for an out-of-the-way irrelevant place.' This perception is deeply rooted in the borough's history and the way it operates independently of the city's other boroughs.

The Fresh Kills Landfill and Political Sentiments

For many years, Staten Island was infamous for hosting the world's largest garbage dump, the Fresh Kills Landfill. Although this site is now a park, its legacy has left a lasting impact on how others perceive the borough. Politically, Staten Island's separateness has a long history. Residents have historically expressed a desire for their own mayor, reflecting a sense of alienation from the city's central administration. These sentiments are not entirely unfounded, given the mayor's controversial tenure that has sometimes left residents feeling ignored or undervalued.

Staten Island: A World Apart

Despite its smaller size, Staten Island is home to approximately 600,000 residents, making it more populous than many U.S. cities. However, it is often overshadowed by the larger and more economically powerful boroughs of Brooklyn, Queens, and Manhattan. The money and power are concentrated in Manhattan, with Brooklyn and Queens boasting large populations and diverse urban scenes. The Bronx, while often portrayed negatively, still holds a significant population of its own.

Geographical and Historical Isolation

Staten Island's geographic isolation contributes to its unique identity. It is an island separated from the rest of the city by the Arthur Kill and the Hudson River. While this isolation can be a source of pride, it also means that the island is not everyone's first choice for a residential location. The Staten Island Ferry, a free public service, moves 70,000 people each day, connecting residents to the rest of the city. The Verrazano-Narrows Bridge, connecting Staten Island to Brooklyn, boasts 13 lanes and carries 202,000 commuters daily. Its opening in 1964 marked the longest suspension bridge in the world, representing a significant achievement in infrastructure.

Beauty and Calmness Amidst the Bustle

While Staten Island may lack the major tourist attractions found in other boroughs, it offers its own unique charm and beauty. The island is known for its great beaches, particularly popular among residents. Snug Harbor has been a hub for teaching new Wikipedia editors, hosting cycling groups, and providing educational activities for kids. Although there may not be major tourist locations, the island offers a peaceful retreat from the bustling city.

Conclusion: Staten Island Deserves More Attention

Staten Island is more than just a forgotten island; it is a vibrant and unique part of New York City. While it may not receive the same level of attention as the other boroughs, its rich history, cultural identity, and natural beauty are worth exploring. Whether you're a longtime resident or a visitor, Staten Island offers a different kind of New York experience—one of calm, beauty, and a strong sense of community.