The Criticisms of Synod on Synodality from Conservative Catholics: Who Really Benefit?

Within the Catholic Church, the concept of Synod on Synodality has sparked considerable debate, particularly among conservative Catholics. While some view it as an opportunity for reform and greater inclusivity, others are wary of its potential implications, especially regarding sexual morality.

Introduction to the Synod on Synodality

The Synod on Synodality, officially known as the Synod of the Synods, was a global gathering of bishops from various dioceses to discuss issues pertinent to Church governance and mission. It aimed to enhance the Church's synodal approach to governance, where the people of God were more involved in decision-making processes.

Criticisms from Conservative Catholics

Impact on Sexual Morality Standards

One of the primary criticisms from conservative Catholics is the concern that looser standards on sexual morality could lead to a significant shift in the Church's traditional teachings. They argue that such changes might benefit educated and wealthy adults who can navigate and take advantage of these changes, leading to a deeper indulgence in their desires without facing the stringent moral guidance historically upheld by the Church.

Effects on Vulnerable Groups

Conservative Catholics are particularly concerned about the potential impact on children and the poorer and less well-educated members of the Church. They argue that these groups often lack the resources and education to protect themselves from exploitation and moral degradation when faced with less stringent sexual morality standards. These individuals may feel their interests are ignored and are more vulnerable to being taken advantage of.

Loud Voices During the Synod

Another point of criticism is the disparity in the voices heard during the Synod. It is argued that the group most likely to have the loudest and most influential voices are those who stand to gain the most from the proposed changes. Educated and wealthy adults, with their resources and networks, are in a prime position to advocate for and benefit from any reforms. This dynamic might overshadow the concerns and needs of those who stand to lose the most.

Engaging All Voices

To address these concerns, it is crucial for the Church to ensure that all voices, especially those often marginalized, are heard and valued. This means creating a more inclusive approach to the Synod on Synodality, where input from all segments of the Church is equally considered.

Conclusion

The Synod on Synodality is a complex and multifaceted issue that requires careful consideration of its potential impacts on different groups within the Church. While positive reforms that enhance inclusivity and engagement are to be welcomed, it is essential that these changes do not come at the expense of moral standards and the welfare of the vulnerable. The Church must work towards a balanced and empathetic approach that ensures that every voice is heard and every individual is protected.