Comparing Test Captains: Virat Kohli vs Steve Smith
While it is subjective to definitively determine who is better between Virat Kohli and Steve Smith, this article will focus on their respective performances in Test cricket and one-day international (ODI) formats. Both captains have earned their place in cricket history, but certain nuances in their careers suggest that one may have an edge in each category.
Ryan Jahani
Despite personal preferences and the inevitability of comparisons, I will present a detailed analysis of the factors that can help us understand who might be considered better in Test cricket as opposed to their ODI performances.
Steven Smith as a Test Captain
Steve Smith, with his unorthodox techniques and innovative field placements, is a master of manipulation in Test cricket. Unlike Kohli, who is admired for his aesthetic batting style and graceful shots, Smith's ability to adapt to various conditions and opponent strategies is unparalleled. His manipulation of field settings often puzzles and frustrates the opposition, making him a formidable force in Test formats. His on-field presence and strategic insights are commendable, reflecting his success as a Test captain.
Virat Kohli: Superior in ODI Format
On the other hand, Virat Kohli's performances in ODI matches highlight his talent as a white-ball batter. He boasts an impressive international record, with numerous centuries and a high conversion rate compared to Smith. Kohli's ability to perform consistently in foreign tours is a significant advantage, as he has averaged close to 90 during his debut as captain in Australia, showcasing his adaptability and resilience. His innate talent for making the game look effortless and his aesthetic batting style make him a favorite among cricket enthusiasts, particularly in limited-overs cricket.
The Verdict: Test Cricket vs. ODI Performance
While Virat Kohli is undoubtedly the better white-ball batsman currently, Steve Smith edges it in Test cricket due to his stellar performances throughout his career. In Test matches, Smith's on-field acumen and strategic play set him apart, making him a more dominant figure in longer formats.
Recent Performances: Ashes Series
Steve Smith had a remarkable run in the Ashes series, where he scored at an average of 110 and briefly dethroned Kohli from the top spot in the ICC Test rankings. However, Smith's success in one series does not negate Kohli’s overall career achievements. Kohli's consistency and international records indicate that he is the current leader in the test rankings and is well on his way to reclaiming his position with upcoming series.
It is also noteworthy that Virat Kohli holds the distinction of being the only batsman at present with an international average of over 50 across all three formats. This makes his performance even more impressive and unparalleled.
Conclusion
Virat Kohli and Steve Smith each have their unique strengths and achievements in cricket. While Smith may have the edge in Test cricket due to his innovative strategies and field placements, Kohli's performances in ODI and T20 formats highlight his adaptability and consistency. As the cricket world continues to evolve, their performance records and adaptability to changing conditions will be key factors in determining the superior captain in the future.